A Protestant friend once told me she knows she will see me in heaven. This was after I shared my story of why I left Protestantism and returned to the Catholic Church. My reversion did not deter her confidence that my salvation, a one-time past event, was secure and certain. The most shocking thing is, as a Catholic, I cannot even say with absolute confidence that I will see myself in heaven!
Now what if in a few years I go back to explain to her that I have since left Catholicism to become a Mormon or a Muslim? Would she then still tell me she knows she will see me in heaven one day? I doubt it. Most likely, her theology would force her to conclude that I was never really saved in the first place—despite previously knowing with certainty that I was saved.
Something is off here on multiple levels. And I don’t blame my friend. I blame the man who came up with a novel idea fifteen hundred years after the start of Christianity.
The Novel Theology of John Calvin
John Calvin, one of the Protestant Reformers, devised an entirely new theology claiming a Christian’s salvation cannot be lost, contrary to the Church Fathers and all theologians up to the 16th century. According to Calvin’s own interpretation of Scripture, once one becomes a legitimately believing Christian, salvation is irrevocable and is therefore certain and secure. For Calvin, it’s not that sin becomes a trivial matter. Rather, God holds his children so closely that they are guaranteed to keep the faith and maintain their salvation. This is what is called the perseverance of the saints or eternal security.
Others after Calvin took this idea further and taught that no sin committed by a Christian, no matter how serious (including murder, adultery, or even apostasy), could jeopardize one’s salvation. This view is commonly referred to as “once saved, always saved.” Since eternal security is a stronger, more defensible position than “once saved, always saved,” I will generally refer to the former throughout the article, but the analysis below applies to both.
In the following section, I will show why Calvinistic proof texts fail to provide compelling support for eternal security when read in context. Then in the conclusion, I will explain why this theology poses a problem not just for Calvinists, but for Protestants in general.
Evaluating Calvinistic Proof Texts
Here I will evaluate three common proof texts offered by proponents of eternal security. By showing that even a few have reasonable explanations that can be interpreted differently, the hope is that one holding to this view realizes a prior theological framework has been read into these texts and that, at the very least, a deeper dive may be needed in order to reconsider the theology of eternal security with fresh eyes.
1“Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life. He does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life” (John 5:24).
A Calvinist will emphasize that this doesn’t say he will have eternal life, but that he has eternal life; indeed, whoever hears my word and believes has passed (past tense) from death to life. It’s also argued that the gift of eternal life cannot be taken away otherwise it wouldn’t be eternal. But if someone possesses something eternal it doesn’t automatically follow that the possession itself is eternal. Just because a gift is freely received, even the gift of eternal life, it does not mean it cannot later be freely rejected.
What Jesus is saying here is that his followers do have eternal life, provided they continue to follow him. This is spelled out elsewhere, such as in the very next chapter of John when Jesus says that whoever feeds on his flesh by partaking of the Eucharist “has eternal life” and “abides” in him (John 6:54, 56). Receiving the Eucharist, or course, is not a one-time past event but something that must be frequented to remain united to Christ.
Jesus explains the importance of abiding in him later in John’s gospel when he says, “If anyone does not abide in me he is thrown away like a branch and withers; and the branches are gathered, thrown into the fire, and burned” (John 15:6). Jesus is the true vine, and believers (not unbelievers) are the branches. If a believer does not remain in Jesus, he is cast away and burned, which means there is a real possibility that Christians can fall away from Jesus.
But a Calvinist may still object and say Scripture affirms we can know we have eternal life which means salvation is certain and secure: “I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life” (1 John 5:13). One problem is that throughout this letter John says there are several ways we can know we truly know Jesus and have eternal life. For example, John says, “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments” (1 John 2:3). And he warns believers that there is sin that leads to death (1 John 5:16) and even ends his letter urging Christians to “keep yourselves from idols” (1 John 5:21). This wouldn’t make any sense if John thought Christians could not lose their salvation by falling into serious sin.
So what Scripture is saying is that we can know we have eternal life because we can know if we are following Jesus who is our one hope, and provided we continue believing in him and keep his commandments, Jesus will bring us to everlasting life.
2“In him you also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it, to the praise of his glory” (Eph 1:13-14).
Those who accept the gospel receive a divine seal, the Holy Spirit, which Paul says elsewhere that we receive at baptism (1 Cor 6:11; 12:13). The Holy Spirit dwelling within us is the guarantee or downpayment of our inheritance to be received in heaven, so doesn’t that mean that our salvation is guaranteed? Not quite.
The Spirit operative within a believer initiates the promise of salvation. The promise is guaranteed, that those who believe in Jesus until the end will be saved, but the individual believer is not guaranteed to maintain that saving union with Christ. It’s not that the Spirit isn’t a strong enough seal to keep believers close to Christ, it’s that even once Christians receive the Spirit they retain the freedom to break the seal, foregoing the inheritance of eternal life promised to them.
Recall the story of the prodigal son. The son was living in communion with his father and asked for his inheritance which he quickly threw away. When the son realized his folly, he returned to the Father repentant. The father didn’t say, “Oh, good to see you again son, but no need to repent or worry; you were always secure in my arms.” No, the father, who represents God, said, “For this my son was dead, and is alive again; he was lost, and is found” (Luke 15:24). The son threw away his inheritance which the father said resulted in his spiritual death. Then, when the son repented and returned, the father said he was spiritually alive again. Thus the son lost then later regained his salvation.
Proponents of eternal security may argue this was just a parable and that falling away is not a real possibility for those in Christ and sealed with the Spirit. But the author of Hebrews says those who “have shared in the Holy Spirit” can fall away (Heb 6:4-6). And consider what Jesus says will happen at the end of the age: “And then many will fall away … But the one who endures to the end will be saved” (Matt 24:10-13). I guess Jesus didn’t join the right Bible study because he didn’t catch onto the idea of “once saved, always saved.”
3“For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 8:38-39).
This beautiful passage from Paul is absolutely true. But what is not mentioned in this list? Sin. It’s true nothing in all creation can separate us from Christ, but we can choose to freely turn away from Christ by committing serious sin. The same goes for when Jesus says no one can snatch one of his sheep out of his hand (John 10:28). Correct, no one can snatch us away, but we can walk away. Just think back to Adam and Eve. Created entirely free from sin, they willingly sinned against God and brought ruin upon themselves and the entire human race.
Interestingly, Paul elsewhere says he’s worried he could be disqualified and lose his salvation (1 Cor 9:27). And he repeatedly warns believers that their salvation could be lost (e.g., Rom 11:22; 1 Cor 10:12; 15:2; 2 Cor 6:1; 11:3; 13:5; Col 1:23; 2:18). But the loss of salvation is not just a theoretical possibility, according to Paul, some have “fallen away from grace” (Gal 5:4) and “swerved from the faith” (1 Tim 6:21).
Conclusion
All this should be sufficient to show that Calvinistic proof texts, perhaps persuasive by themselves or at least when strung together as a list, do not hold up under scrutiny. For those interested in a more detailed Biblical analysis, which includes reference to Protestant scholars who reject the idea that salvation cannot be lost, I would recommend the chapter “Eternal Security” from Trent Horn’s book The Case for Catholicism.
On a final note, many Protestants rightly recognize that this dispute cannot be resolved by Protestants since it is a matter of one’s personal interpretation of Scripture, but then they too quickly conclude that this is therefore something where Christians can simply agree to disagree. Here I would urge caution. Since eternal security and “once saved, always saved” theology is a matter directly touching upon salvation, one would do well to wonder why a problem of such serious magnitude with drastic practical implications cannot be resolved by Christians who claim the Bible is their sole infallible rule of faith. To put this another way, the question of whether Christians can lose their salvation isn’t just a problem for Calvinist Christians, it’s a problem for Protestant Christians, including those who agree that salvation can be lost. Those curious where “Bible alone” Christianity falls short of Jesus’s plan for his disciples should check out my article 5 Problems with Sola Scriptura.





